Take Back Healthcare

News and analysis about the uninsured, single-payer, employee health benefits, medical insurance, medical tourism, Medicare, Medicaid, health costs, drug costs, the Canadian and other foreign plans, and more.

<< Clinton, Frist Introduce Bill To Establish Health Information Standards   |   WEBLOG   |   Cancer Center Spurs Economic Development Efforts in Tampa Bay >>

What Do We Pay Doctors to Do?

Challenging many widely held assumptions about health care, Arnold Kling argues that doctors should be paid - not for their results, not for their efforts, and not per patient - but rather for their adhering to prescribed treatment guidelines.

According to Kling, there are four possible methods to pay doctors:

Kling argues that capitation creates the medical rationing that recently caused the Canadian Supreme Court to strike down provisions of the Quebec medical system . Paying doctors on outcomes will not work because too many factors are beyond their control, he adds.

Rewarding on effort is the current American system, which he characterizes as "activist medicine" in another article. Activist medicine is the tendency to pour greater and greater amounts of effort into medical treatment in return for questionable added medical benefits.

This activist approach, he argues, is what makes the American healthcare system so expensive.

He concludes that paying on guidelines should therefore be considered. Some outside expert board should establish treatments for illnesses which doctors should follow.

Of course, it would be no small trick to set up uniform medical guidelines. Nor would it be easy to change them, once they were put in place. Look at how difficult it has been to change America to the metric system of measurement. Imagine some effort to establish a rational system of English spelling. Try, just try, to simplify the tax code. Similar problems would plague any effort to modify uniform medical standards.

Still, Kling is a clear, original thinker and a good writer. He should be read by anyone wanting to increase his understanding of how and why the American medical system is the way it now is.


Posted by: Duncan Kinder on Jun 18, 05 | 10:33 am | Profile

Want more information about this topic? Search the web or this site

Web www.takebackhealthcare.info


Notify me when someone replies to this post?

Powered by pMachine